Garrett Taylor: Allstate Insurance - New Albany, Indiana

Parker E.

I had an excellent experience working with Garrett Taylor and his team at Allstate Insurance. From the start, Garrett was professional, knowledgeable, and incredibly attentive to my needs. He took the time to thoroughly explain all of my options and helped me choose the best coverage for my situation.

What really sets Garrett apart is his dedication to customer service. Whether it was answering my questions promptly or ensuring I fully understood my policy, Garrett went above and beyond to make me feel confident and well-protected. It’s clear he genuinely cares about his clients and their peace of mind.

If you’re looking for an insurance agent who combines expertise, reliability, and a personal touch, Garrett Taylor is the one to call. I highly recommend him and his team for all your insurance needs!

Alyssa B.

I have been using this agency for 21 years, since I’ve been 16 years old; I think that should speak for itself! I’ve had an excellent experience with Joey, which has transitioned smoothly to Garrett.

Highly recommend this agency. I know it’s popular to shop for the cheapest rate. However, nothing beats peace of mind to know you’re covered properly by a credible agency.

Future S.

Not only did Garrett get me a better price than what I was paying at Geico, he took care of everything! He and his team then took care of two referrals by getting them better rates as well. The team responds quickly, kindly, and professionally! I’m definitely in good hands!

hotshot Z.

Allstate and the office of Garrett Taylor goes above and beyond in customer service! Very friendly, knowledgeable and always replies back to you quickly! Definitely recommend Allatate for your insurance needs. I have been with them for over 30 years!

Annjanette C.

Garrett and Staff is wonderful! Customer Service is Excellent and I have no issues with adding or dropping vehicles when I had to. GREAT TEAM

Stephanie B.

Garrett did a great job making explaining insurance and licensing to me. He made sure I understood and was willing to take time to answer any other questions.

Jennifer H.

We have been with Allstate for 25+ years and everyone is so nice and helpful! After our agent retired and Garrett took over it’s been a smooth transition and we couldn’t ask for a better Agency.

Rachael R.

It's insurance. I could get it cheaper but would that be better?
Before his death, my father was happy with how they handled his roof repair.
I'm happy with how they handled my daughter's car accident. (Not her fault anyway)
I'm not happy at the high cost of my homeowner's policy but I haven't shopped around yet.
I also have issues with the app. I cannot change payment options there.
I get a credit for auto-pay but if I want to pay early, I'm penalized for that.